Logo for Buddy Breeds Buddy Breeds

Border Collie vs Irish Setter vs Collie

Three friendly breeds enter—one emerges as your best match. Use the trait grids below to spot practical differences in lifestyle fit.

Full body image of a Border Collie
size

Border Collies are medium-sized dogs, weighing 30-45 lbs, with a height of 18-22 inches.

energy level

Border Collies have a high energy level, requiring plenty of physical and mental stimulation.

exercise needs

Border Collies need extensive exercise, including daily walks, runs, and mental challenges like training or dog sports.

trainability

Border Collies are highly intelligent and trainable, excelling in obedience and various dog sports.

intelligence

Border Collies are considered one of the most intelligent dog breeds and can learn a wide range of commands and tasks.

adaptability

Border Collies can adapt to different living situations, but they thrive in environments with plenty of space to run and exercise.

with kids

Border Collies can be good with children, but their herding instincts may cause them to nip or chase. Proper supervision and training are essential.

with other pets

Border Collies can get along with other pets, but early socialization and proper training are important to manage their herding instincts.

in cold climates

Border Collies can tolerate colder temperatures thanks to their double coat, but proper protection is necessary during extreme cold.

in hot climates

Border Collies can tolerate hot climates but need to be monitored for signs of overheating during exercise.

shedding

Border Collies have a double coat that sheds seasonally, requiring regular brushing to manage shedding.

grooming

Border Collies require regular grooming, including brushing, bathing, and trimming to keep their coats clean and healthy.

bark tendency

Border Collies have average bark tendencies and may bark for various reasons, such as alerting their owners or during playtime.

health issues

Border Collies may experience some health issues and require additional care and attention, such as regular veterinary checkups, preventative care, and potential medication or treatments.

Full body image of a Irish Setter
size

Irish Setters are large dogs, weighing 60-70 lbs, with a height of 25-27 inches.

energy level

Irish Setters have a high energy level and need plenty of physical activity to stay happy and healthy.

exercise needs

Irish Setters require a lot of exercise, including daily walks, play sessions, and activities like fetch or dog sports.

trainability

Irish Setters are intelligent and trainable, but they can be easily distracted. Consistent, positive reinforcement is key.

intelligence

Irish Setters are highly intelligent dogs and can excel in various dog sports and activities, such as agility and obedience.

adaptability

Irish Setters can adapt to various living situations but are not well-suited for small apartments due to their high energy level.

with kids

Irish Setters are good with children, as they are generally friendly, playful, and patient.

with other pets

Irish Setters can get along well with other pets, especially when raised together.

in cold climates

Irish Setters can tolerate colder temperatures due to their thick, medium-length coats.

in hot climates

Irish Setters can tolerate hot climates but need to be monitored for signs of overheating during exercise.

shedding

Irish Setters have a medium-length coat and shed moderately, requiring regular grooming.

grooming

Irish Setters require regular grooming, including brushing and occasional trimming, to keep their coats clean and healthy.

bark tendency

Irish Setters have average bark tendencies and may bark for various reasons, such as alerting their owners or during playtime.

health issues

Irish Setters are generally healthy, but regular veterinary checkups and preventative care are still necessary.

Full body image of a Collie
size

Collies are elegant and well-proportioned, standing 22-26 inches tall and weighing 50-75 lbs.

energy level

Collies have moderate energy levels and enjoy daily walks and playtime, but they're not overly demanding.

exercise needs

Collies require regular exercise, such as walks and playtime, to keep them mentally and physically fit.

trainability

Intelligent and eager to please, Collies are easy to train and excel in obedience, agility, and herding activities.

intelligence

Collies are highly intelligent dogs, known for their problem-solving skills and quick learning abilities.

adaptability

Collies can adapt to various living situations, but they prefer having access to outdoor space for exercise and play.

with kids

Collies are gentle, patient, and loving, making them wonderful companions for children.

with other pets

Collies usually get along well with other dogs and pets, especially if socialized from an early age.

in cold climates

Collies have a thick double coat that helps them tolerate cold weather, but they still need proper shelter and protection.

in hot climates

Collies can manage in hot climates, but they require shade, water, and limited exercise during the hottest parts of the day.

shedding

Collies shed seasonally, with heavier shedding during coat changes. Regular brushing can help minimize shedding.

grooming

Collies need regular brushing to keep their coats clean and prevent matting.

bark tendency

Collies have average bark tendencies and may bark for various reasons, such as alerting their owners or during playtime.

health issues

Collies are generally healthy, but regular veterinary checkups and preventative care are still necessary.